The Paradox of Plenty
A land once cradled by the mighty Indus River—a system
nourished by Himalayan glaciers and monsoon rains—now grapples with an
existential threat to its water and food security. The catastrophic floods of
2010, 2022, and now the looming specter of 2025, have laid bare the
vulnerabilities of the nation's economic spine.
Entire districts submerged, millions displaced, and billions
in losses—these are not mere acts of nature. While the narrative conveniently
blames "river fury" or "climate change," the true culprits
are a trifecta of institutional apathy, corruption, and staggering incompetence
in the very bodies created to shield the nation from such disasters.
The Global Blueprint: Universities as Clinics of
Solutions
Around the world, leading universities function as dynamic
"clinics of solutions." They don't just study problems; they
diagnose, innovate, and prescribe treatments.
|
Global Leader |
Intervention |
Outcome |
|
TU Delft & Deltares (Netherlands) |
Advanced flood management & delta works |
Transformed a low-lying nation into the world's benchmark
for water resilience; exported models to Bangladesh, Vietnam, and
post-Katrina New Orleans. |
|
Israeli Universities |
Pioneered drip irrigation |
Turned deserts into verdant, agricultural powerhouses,
optimizing every drop of water. |
|
IIT Roorkee, Kanpur, Kharagpur (India) |
Generations of water engineers |
Designed dams, revitalized irrigation, and managed
groundwater at a colossal scale. |
|
Oxford/Stockholm SIWI, Colorado University |
Transboundary water diplomacy |
Translated water science into statecraft, mediating
conflicts on the Nile, Mekong, and Colorado rivers. |
These institutions are healing forces, converting knowledge
into security and peace.
Pakistan's Painful Paradox: Centers of Excellence,
Epicenters of Failure
Pakistan's story is uniquely tragic. Despite having over 133
engineering universities and specialized centers like:
- Center
of Excellence in Water Resources Engineering (Lahore)
- USA-Pakistan
Center for Advanced Studies in Water (Mehran University)
- Water
Management Research Center (University of Agriculture, Faisalabad)
...the nation has little tangible research to show for it.
The Grand Disconnect: These centers, conceived
to be the beating heart of applied research, have become monuments to failure.
They boast state-of-the-art laboratories, foreign-educated faculty, and hefty
budgets, yet their output is often limited to dusty academic papers with
tenuous connections to ground realities. The focus is on publishing in
"high-impact factor" journals on irrelevant topics, not on solving
Pakistan's pressing crises.
Key Failure: Floodplain Management
- The
Evidence: Residential societies sprung up on the banks of the
Ravi near Lahore. Illegal hotels proliferated along the Swat River.
- The
Result: When the floods came, the unzoned embankments collapsed
like paper walls. The institutions mandated to prevent this were
conspicuously silent, year after year.
The Great Distraction: Hijacking the Climate Narrative
Into this void stepped opportunists. For over a decade,
Pakistan’s climate discourse was hijacked by a chorus of self-proclaimed
experts and ministers who peddled a simplistic, misleading mantra: "The
glaciers are melting."
This was a distortion of science. The reality is far more
nuanced.
- The
Karakoram Anomaly: A term coined by geographer Kenneth Hewitt in
the 1980s, it describes the surprising stability—and in some cases,
growth—of high-altitude glaciers in the Karakoram range, bucking the
global trend of retreat.
- Evolving
Science: Recent studies, like the one led by Fuming Xie
(2023), suggest this anomaly may be weakening under increasing heat
stress. Work by Farinotti et al. (2024) in their seminal
study "The state and future of the Karakoram Anomaly" continues
to advance this complex field.
While local experts like engineer Arshad H. Abbasi (co-author
of this piece) warned policymakers against this scientific misrepresentation,
their voices were drowned out by the sensationalists. Ministers and so-called
experts transformed climate change into a vanity industry, leveraging donor
funds and media airtime, deceiving millions whose survival depends on the Indus
Basin.
The Unspoken Truth: Yes, climate change is real,
and Pakistan is a victim. But using it as an excuse for incompetence—especially
the failure to curb industrial pollution—is the true failure. Natural shocks
only become disasters because of the absence of resilient systems.
The Architecture of Failure: How HEC Buried Pakistan’s
Future
The decline of research governance is epitomized by the
Higher Education Commission (HEC). Instead of mandating applied research with
clear performance indicators, the HEC buried the nation's future under
irrelevant metrics. Promotions and prestige were tied to publishing in
journals, often on topics completely divorced from Pakistan's crises.
There was no urgent drive to:
- Design
flood prediction models.
- Advocate
for critical dam storage.
- Improve
irrigation efficiency.
- Manage
groundwater sustainably.
Worse, bizarre projects like the "2011
Scientific Equipment Rehabilitation" secured public funds and
propelled its principal investigator to a Vice-Chancellor's post. In what
rational world does a maintenance report qualify as 'research' while millions
drown?
The Devastating Cost: By the Numbers
Pakistan's water crisis is not looming; it is already here.
|
Indicator |
Pakistan's Status |
Recommended Level |
Implication |
|
Per Capita Water Availability |
<750 m³/year (World Bank) |
1,000 m³/year |
Officially a water-scarce nation, edging towards absolute
scarcity. |
|
Agricultural Water Use |
>90% |
- |
The largest sector by consumption, yet relies on wasteful
flood irrigation. |
|
Storage Capacity |
~30 days |
120 days (for arid countries) |
Critically low buffer for droughts and dry seasons. |
|
Groundwater Stress |
Extremely High |
Sustainable Recharge |
The Indus Basin is one of the most overstressed aquifers
globally, depleting faster than it can recharge. |
What remains is often poisoned by industrial waste and
agricultural runoff. Children in cities drink contaminated water, while farmers
irrigate with saline water—a silent killer of soil fertility.
Need for Accountability, Not Alms
This narrative is not an appeal for global charity. It is a
call for accountability.
- Audit
the Institutions: Donors must demand a forensic audit of every
Water Excellence Center and the performance of every HEC official from
2000 to 2025. Without this reckoning, nothing will change.
- Reclaim
the Narrative: We must silence the cacophony of pseudo-experts
and replace it with evidence-based policy. The 1960 Indus Waters Treaty is
a bedrock of peace; questioning its foundation is a dangerous game that
plays with the nation's survival.
- Learn
from Global Clinics: Emulate the success of the University of
Cape Town (averted "Day Zero"), ETH Zürich (integrated climate
models), and China's Tsinghua University ("sponge cities" for
urban flood management).
A Civilization's Choice
Pakistan’s water tragedy is not inevitable; it is a man-made
crisis of negligence. The most profound betrayal is not from the rivers, but
from the very Centers of Excellence and engineering faculties that promised to
be the nation’s shield.
They have abandoned their post, leaving a void filled by
opportunists who turn every flood into theater, every dam into a conspiracy,
and every treaty into a weapon of discord.
Unless Pakistan learns from the world and its institutions
start to function as true stewards, the Indus will write the same verdict for
this civilization as it did for Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa over 5,000 years ago.
Civilizations are not defeated by their rivers. They are
defeated by silence, incompetence, and betrayal.
Sources & Further Reading:
- World
Bank. (2022). Pakistan: Water Sector Profile. https://www.worldbank.org
- Farinotti,
D., et al. (2024). The state and future of the Karakoram Anomaly. Nature
Reviews Earth & Environment.
- Xie,
F., et al. (2023). Weakening of the Karakoram Anomaly under
intense warming. [Journal of Climate].
- Hewitt,
K. (2005). The Karakoram Anomaly? Glacier Expansion and the 'Elevation
Effect,' Karakoram Himalaya. Mountain Research and Development.
- World
Resources Institute. (2023). Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas. https://www.wri.org/aqueduct
No comments:
Post a Comment